Print the page
Increase font size
SEC Rejects Bitcoin ETF

Posted November 17, 2021

Aaron Gentzler

By Aaron Gentzler

SEC Rejects Bitcoin ETF

The decision on a new VanEck Bitcoin ETF came out Friday after the SEC delayed its determination in September.

The much-anticipated Bitcoin ETF -- this time based on the spot price of Bitcoin instead of Bitcoin futures -- was smacked down by the SEC.

The SEC’s decision is not unsurprising since SEC Chair Gary Gensler, who was thought to have been a booster for digital currencies, has done an about-face on crypto.

On news of the jettisoned ETF Friday, Bitcoin dipped about 1%... and has been choppy since.

Send your opinions to, TheRundownFeedback@StPaulResearch.com

Your Rundown for Wednesday, November 17, 2021...

2022: Year of the Physical Bitcoin ETF

“The SEC rejected VanEck’s filing for a physical bitcoin ETF,” notes CNBC, “saying it still lacked confidence that the bitcoin market was free of manipulation and fraud to approve the product.”

(Which is rich. How confident are you, reader, that stocks themselves are “free of manipulation and fraud”? It’s almost laughable. Almost.)

Two futures Bitcoin ETFs -- the ProShares Bitcoin Strategy ETF (BITO) and the Valkyrie Bitcoin Strategy ETF (BTF) -- started trading at the end October. Plus, VanEck’s Bitcoin Strategy ETF (XBTF), with the lowest fees of the three, started trading yesterday.

Invesco, on the other hand, rescinded its SEC application for its own Bitcoin futures ETF; instead, “Invesco is now looking ahead to the pure-play version,” CNBC says.

“I wasn’t surprised that the SEC rejected the application last week,” says Anna Paglia of Invesco. “I do think that some more regulation is something that the SEC is expecting before approving the next application, but I’m counting on 2022 as the year for a pure-play ETF.”

At the same time, she admits this might be a case of “wishful thinking.”

ETF Trends’ David Nadig agrees: “Until we get clear regulation of the underlying coin markets themselves for U.S. investors, I just don’t think we’re going to cross that hurdle.

“I think a real solid physical bitcoin ETF is probably at least a year off at this point,” he concludes.

Market Rundown for Wednesday, Nov. 17, 2021

S&P 500 futures are down 6 points to 4,695.

Oil is down 1% to 79.93 for a barrel of WTI.

Gold’s up $12.90 per ounce to $1,867.10. 

Bitcoin’s up $280 to $59,885.

Send your comments and questions to, TheRundownFeedback@StPaulResearch.com

We’ll talk more Friday; until then, take care…

For The Rundown,

Aaron Gentzler

Aaron Gentzler
Editor, The Rundown
TheRundownFeedback@StPaulResearch.com

Bye, Boomer Schumer

Bye, Boomer Schumer

Posted November 20, 2026

By Emily Clancy

After winning back the Senate, Chuck Schumer faces a challenge from Bernie Sanders’ unlikely pick for majority leader.
Adam’s Wife Preps for Doomsday

Adam’s Wife Preps for Doomsday

Posted November 17, 2026

By Matt Insley

From mysterious flight groundings to growing fears of infrastructure disruption, guest editor Adam Sharp makes the case for old-fashioned preparedness.
A Central Bank Loses Its Chairman

A Central Bank Loses Its Chairman

Posted November 16, 2026

By Matt Insley

Jensen Huang’s resignation has rattled Nvidia, but the bigger story may be what happens to the AI boom without his financial backing.
Mourning in America

Mourning in America

Posted November 13, 2026

By Matt Insley

Millions of Americans moved to the Sunbelt after 2020. Did they change its politics? The voter data tells a messier story.
Massie’s Last Stand

Massie’s Last Stand

Posted November 11, 2026

By Matt Insley

On his way out of Congress, Rep. Thomas Massie launches one final showdown with Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth.
The Risky Business of Life Insurance

The Risky Business of Life Insurance

Posted November 09, 2026

By Emily Clancy

A new report reveals how deeply insurance companies are invested in private credit — and what that could mean for life insurance and annuity holders.