Print the page
Increase font size
Vance Casts Critical Tiebreaker

Posted January 27, 2025

Matt Insley

By Matt Insley

Vance Casts Critical Tiebreaker

We’re closing the loop this morning on a key cabinet confirmation, but we’re currently researching other major stories, including market jitters… China’s AI breakthrough… and tensions between President Trump and “first buddy” Elon Musk. But first…

In a razor-thin vote on Friday, President Trump’s nominee for Secretary of Defense, Pete Hegseth, was confirmed by the U.S. Senate.

The Senate floor was tense as the votes were tallied, resulting in an initial 50-50 split. This after three Republican senators broke ranks with their party to oppose Hegseth’s nomination: Lisa Murkowski of Alaska, Susan Collins of Maine and former GOP leader Mitch McConnell of Kentucky.

  • Their dissent, combined with unified Democratic opposition, meant Vice President Vance cast the decisive tie-breaking vote.

This vote marked only the second time in U.S. history that a vice president has been called upon to break a tie for a cabinet nominee, with the first instance being Mike Pence’s tie-breaking vote for Betsy DeVos as Education Secretary in 2017.

The close nature of the vote underscores the controversy surrounding Hegseth's nomination, which was clouded by serious allegations.

Despite these concerns, the Trump administration stood firmly behind Hegseth, with the President expressing confidence in his nominee even as the vote hung in the balance.

The vote further highlights the significance of the vice presidential role in shaping the nation’s leadership…

Your Rundown for Monday, January 27, 2025...

A Closer Look at Constitutional Succession

And while JD Vance played a significant role in getting out the vote for Trump, after Election Day, Vance’s role seemed more muted.

Nevertheless, in the hypothetical scenario where President Trump were to die in office, the Constitutional process for succession would immediately come into play.

According to the 25th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, Vice President Vance would automatically assume the role of President.

This transition would be immediate and would not require any additional voting or confirmation process.

As President, Vance would then have the responsibility of nominating a new Vice President.

The process of selecting a new Vice President under these circumstances is outlined in Section 2 of the 25th Amendment — a process which prevents the President from unilaterally appointing a successor.

  • While the President nominates the Vice President in this scenario, the final decision rests with Congress. Both the House and Senate must confirm the nominee by a majority vote.
  • Interestingly, a tie vote could potentially occur in the Senate. If this were to happen, the process would be at an impasse; there is no provision for breaking a tie in this specific situation.
  • The President would then need to nominate a different candidate for Vice President, restarting the confirmation process.

President Vance, therefore, would likely consider a nominee who could gain Congressional approval as well as someone who could effectively support Vance’s administration.

In the interim period before a new Vice President is confirmed, the Speaker of the House would be next in line for the presidency after Vance, followed by the President pro tempore of the Senate.

However, this would only come into play if something were to happen to President Vance before a new Vice President was confirmed.

This constitutional process underlines the critical role that figures like JD Vance play in ensuring the continuity of government leadership and spotlights the importance of having a clear line of succession.

[Reader: Who would you nominate as Vice President if JD Vance suddenly found himself thrust into the presidency? We want to hear your feedback on the most compelling candidates.]

Market Rundown for Monday, Jan. 27, 2025

S&P 500 futures are down 2% to 6,000.

Oil’s down 0.75% to $74.12 for a barrel of WTI.

Gold is down 0.45% to $2,766.40 per ounce.

And Bitcoin’s down almost 4% to $100,845.

The Daredevil in Pink Tights

The Daredevil in Pink Tights

Posted June 30, 2025

By Matt Insley

A spectacle that occurred on this date in history was called “the wonder of the age.” Today, Trump’s political tightrope walk is no less perilous.
Star Geologist On “Birthright” Companies

Star Geologist On “Birthright” Companies

Posted June 27, 2025

By Matt Insley

Notes from the underground…
Iran’s Energy Chokepoint: Strait of Hormuz Fallout

Iran’s Energy Chokepoint: Strait of Hormuz Fallout

Posted June 25, 2025

By Matt Insley

The Strait of Hormuz crisis underscores the risks of dependence on global energy chokepoints. America’s true advantage lies beneath its own land
The Essential “American Birthright” Playbook

The Essential “American Birthright” Playbook

Posted June 23, 2025

By Matt Insley

The following guide breaks down the process — investing in mining stocks — into three clear steps, with specific rules for both major and junior miners.
RSVP: Steer Our Next “American Birthright” Conversation

RSVP: Steer Our Next “American Birthright” Conversation

Posted June 20, 2025

By Matt Insley

Whether we’re debating the future of MAGA — or learning to invest in America’s mineral wealth — your engagement makes this community so special.
Tucker, Trump and MAGA’s Rift

Tucker, Trump and MAGA’s Rift

Posted June 18, 2025

By Matt Insley

One issue might split the MAGA movement: the U.S. must avoid entanglement in another “forever war.”